Quantcast
Channel: Comments on: Scotland’s Future: Devo-Max or just Devo-Maybe?
Browsing all 11 articles
Browse latest View live

By: Richard Thomson

But as Jim Callaghan said to Winnie Ewing c.1974: “It’s not the 11 seats you have that worry me, it’s all the second places.”

View Article



By: Alasdair Stirling

Maybe you know something I don’t know, but I have no knowledge of any public commitment by Ming Campbell or the Scottish Liberal Democratic Party on any specific measure for enhancing devolution. Just...

View Article

By: Alasdair Stirling

I covered the creation of the Scottish Parliament in the seven events of devolution by referencing to the 1998 Scotland Act. The point I am making is that the remits of the Scottish Grand Committee and...

View Article

By: Alasdair Stirling

I have no doubt that the Scottish Government could (and perhaps should) address exam standards; however if that is the extent of the Scottish Parliament’s remit you kind of make my point. If we are to...

View Article

By: Alasdair Stirling

There is only one problem with delivering a Devo-Max settlement. It requires the agreement of the English, Welsh and Northern Irish voters (or their MPs). However, things really only get interesting...

View Article


Image may be NSFW.
Clik here to view.

By: Alasdair Stirling

You have no idea of the depths of my cynicism Reject all authority you cannot justify by reason!

View Article

By: Chris

Type your comment here Doug Daniel: Well, even if we take it as being a process to achieve a specific outcome (delivering a fairer Scottish society), devolution has thus fair failed to do this since we...

View Article

By: Chris

Type your comment here null: Maybe you know something I don’t know, but I have no knowledge of any public commitment by Ming Campbell or the Scottish Liberal Democratic Party on any specific measure...

View Article


By: Commenter

no politician To be fair, the SNP has said they would even put a ‘devo something’ option on the ballot. You can claim ‘they’re bluffing’ but bluffs can be called if unionist parties actually want...

View Article


By: Doug Daniel

Is anyone proposing a more redistributive tax system for Scotland? SGP and SSP? As for putting up income tax and council tax at the moment, neither can be done in a progressive manner. Council Tax is a...

View Article

By: Chris

Type your comment here Andrew Smith: It was people like Scottish Labour Action who fought for devolution – it was not the UK Labour Party. The UK Labour Party per se had no particular interest in...

View Article
Browsing all 11 articles
Browse latest View live




Latest Images